Album: Symphony No. 1 in D major
Composer: Gustav Mahler
Orchestra: Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich
Conductor: Paavo Järvi
Label: Alpha Classics
Release: Autumn 2025
Available on all streaming platforms
By Damián Autorino
Editor at Moto Perpetuo
A new chapter in Zürich’s Mahler tradition
The Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich has a long and distinctive relationship with Mahler’s music. Volkmar Andreae — who shaped orchestral life in Zürich for nearly half a century — conducted the city’s first known performance of Symphony No. 1 in 1915, establishing a tradition that continues to this day.
More than a century later, Paavo Järvi and the orchestra continue that lineage with a new recording of the Symphony No. 1, the second instalment in their ongoing Mahler cycle following last year’s Fifth. For Järvi, Mahler is inseparable from the history of music itself: “Mahler encompasses the whole of the history of music that went before him… This is young Mahler, still hopeful, believing in the goodness of the world. We badly need this kind of music right now.”
Hearing Mahler’s score with uncommon clarity
From the opening “sound of nature”, Järvi shapes a reading that foregrounds the architecture of the symphony. Lines emerge with striking ease, and the orchestra’s internal dialogue feels unusually well-balanced. Instead of weight or grandeur for their own sake, the interpretation highlights how the music unfolds from within — from the song-like gestures of the first movement to the rustic dance of the second, the sombre procession of the third, and the eruptive energy of the finale.
The Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich responds with playing of remarkable finesse. Individual colours stand out vividly yet remain fully integrated into the whole, allowing listeners to grasp how motifs shift, return and transform across the four movements. Mahler’s writing feels fully illuminated, its scale and detail held together with natural coherence.
“The so-called Titan”
The booklet essay by Ulrike Thiele revisits the complex history of the symphony’s early versions. Mahler briefly associated the work with Jean Paul’s novel Titan, assigning movement titles and even including Blumine as a second movement. Misunderstandings eventually led him to withdraw both the programme and the title; what remained was simply Symphony in D major. Still, as Järvi notes, the original concept — a young man’s inner journey — can be felt throughout the music, even without external narrative cues.
Mahler composed most of the symphony in the spring of 1888, and echoes of his Songs of a Wayfarer appear in the first and third movements. There is also the curious presence of Frère Jacques in a minor key, transformed into a sombre march before being overtaken by the turbulence of the finale. These elements, woven into the symphonic fabric, reveal a composer already probing the emotional and psychological landscapes that would define his later works.
A welcome new cycle
With this release, Järvi and the Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich reaffirm the artistic purpose of building a complete Mahler cycle — an undertaking that requires long-term vision, technical discipline and a shared sense of musical identity. Their partnership brings fresh vitality to repertoire that remains central to concert life. And with the First Symphony, Zürich reconnects with a score that has been part of its musical narrative for more than a century.
Subscribe to our newsletter